The £165m Warning. Why Dawlish Will Fail Again

The Dawlish sea wall has become a symbol of Britain's coastal railway vulnerability. After £165 million of public investment, the line still faces the same fundamental threat that cut Cornwall off from the rest of England for eight weeks in 2014. The cliffs behind the railway are still crumbling, and the government has quietly paused the work needed to stabilise them.

The 2014 Collapse That Cost £1.2 Billion

In February 2014, a winter storm triggered a landslip at Dawlish that severed the only rail link to Cornwall. The main line runs along the sea wall, perched between the English Channel and steep sandstone cliffs. When the cliff gave way, it took the track with it.

The repair took eight weeks. During that time, Devon and Cornwall were isolated from the national rail network. The economic cost to the South West was estimated at £1.2 billion. Tourism suffered, supply chains broke down, and the region's economy took years to fully recover.

The images of tracks suspended in mid-air became emblematic of Britain's ageing infrastructure. Politicians promised action. Engineers proposed solutions. Money was allocated.

What £165 Million Actually Bought

Since 2014, Network Rail has spent £165 million on sea defences. The work included a higher, stronger sea wall designed to withstand the increasingly violent storms that climate change is bringing to the Channel coast.

The new wall is impressive engineering. It is higher, more robust, and better equipped to handle wave action than the Victorian original. But it addresses the wrong problem.

The 2014 collapse was not caused by the sea wall failing. It was caused by the cliffs behind the railway giving way. The sea wall held. The land above it did not.

The Paused Project That Matters

Phase 5 of the Dawlish resilience programme involves stabilising the cliffs near Teignmouth, just north of Dawlish. This is where the 2014 landslip occurred. The geology here is particularly vulnerable, with sandstone layers prone to water ingress and freeze-thaw damage.

The Department for Transport has paused this phase indefinitely. The reason given is cost. The stabilisation work involves drilling, rock bolting, and potentially realigning the railway inland through tunnel sections. The price tag runs into hundreds of millions more.

Storm Ingrid Proved the Risk Remains

In January 2026, Storm Ingrid caused fresh disruptions on the Dawlish line. Waves overtopped the new sea wall. Services were suspended. While the wall itself performed as designed, the closure demonstrated that the railway remains hostage to weather.

More concerning was a smaller landslip near Teignmouth during the same storm. This was not on the scale of 2014, but it occurred in the exact area where Phase 5 works are paused. The cliffs are still moving.

Why This Matters Beyond Devon

Dawlish is not just a local issue. The railway through Devon and Cornwall is a vital economic artery. It carries freight, commuters, and millions of tourists annually. The closure of this line does not just inconvenience holidaymakers. It isolates an entire region.

The South West contributes approximately £60 billion annually to the UK economy. Cornwall alone relies on tourism for nearly one-third of its economic activity. When the railway closes, hotels empty, restaurants close, and businesses fail.

The 2014 closure demonstrated how fragile this connection is. The response since then has addressed the symptoms but not the disease. A stronger sea wall is welcome, but it is irrelevant if the cliff falls on the track.

The Engineering Options

Several solutions have been proposed for the cliff stabilisation challenge. The most ambitious involves boring a new inland route through the hills behind Teignmouth, bypassing the most vulnerable coastal section entirely. This would cost an estimated £3-5 billion and take a decade to complete.

More modest proposals focus on targeted cliff stabilisation, improved drainage, and early warning systems. These are cheaper but remain unproven at scale. The geology of the South Devon coast is notoriously difficult.

Network Rail maintains that the current monitoring and maintenance regime is sufficient. They point to the successful performance of the new sea wall during recent storms. But they acknowledge that the cliff risk cannot be eliminated without Phase 5 work.

The Political Calculus

Infrastructure spending is always a balance of cost against risk. The £165 million already spent was politically necessary after 2014. The images of a broken railway were too powerful to ignore.

Now, with no immediate crisis, the temptation is to defer further spending. The Department for Transport faces competing demands from the North, the Midlands, and other regions with ageing infrastructure. Dawlish has had its share.

But this calculus ignores the inevitability of the next failure. Climate change is increasing storm intensity and rainfall. The geology is not improving. The next significant landslip is a question of when, not if.

What Travellers Should Know

For visitors to Devon and Cornwall, the Dawlish line remains the most scenic rail route in England. The views across the English Channel are spectacular. The engineering is impressive. The experience is unique.

But travellers should be aware of the fragility. Winter travel carries a higher risk of disruption. Check weather forecasts and service updates before travelling. Have backup plans for reaching your destination if the line closes.

CrossCountry services to Penzance have alternative routing options via Bristol and Exeter if the coastal line closes. Local buses can cover shorter distances. Car hire from Exeter is an option for essential travel.

The Bottom Line

Dawlish represents a microcosm of Britain's infrastructure challenges. We can build impressive defences against the symptoms of problems. Addressing root causes is harder, more expensive, and less politically rewarding.

The £165 million sea wall is a success on its own terms. But the railway it protects remains as vulnerable as it was in 2014. The next storm season will bring new tests. Sooner or later, the cliffs will remind us that geology does not negotiate.

When that happens, the question will not be whether we should have spent more. It will be why we spent so much solving the wrong problem.

---

**Sources**

- [BBC News: Dawlish railway storm damage and repairs](https://www.bbc.co.uk/news)

- [Network Rail: Dawlish sea wall project](https://www.networkrail.co.uk)

- [House of Commons Library: Dawlish railway resilience](https://commonslibrary.parliament.uk)